Bailey Built, via Realcomp)
Tastes differ, sometimes wildly. That's as true in architecture as in fashion, food, music and art. Still, it can be hard not to judge.
Consider this architectural rendering of three "luxe" condos that will replace a knockdown at 4530 Commonwealth St. near West Forest Avenue in Detroit's evolving Woodbridge neighborhood -- an area recognized since 1980 on the National Register of Historic Places.
The bold-looking project is "set to break ground in August and slated for a spring 2020 completion," editor Aaron Mondry posts at Curbed Detroit. He cuts to the meat in paragraph one:
Woodbridge is mostly known for its tree-lined streets and historic single-family homes built in the early 20th century. A new development will be a rare break from that mold.
He notes later that "multi-story condominiums aren’t common in Woodbridge west of Trumbull Avenue," and adds that the two developers "say they worked hard to maintain the general feel of the neighborhood by including brick masonry, porches and similar color palettes."
Whether the design by Bailey Built of Grosse Pointe Woods succeeds is in the eyes of each beholder. Opinions about the Levels Commonwealth design illustration flow at Reddit's Detroit forum, where these are among two dozen posts Friday:
- Isolated, the building is not bad. The problem is that it looks so out of place in a neighborhood with older homes.
- At least it looks pretty.
- Completely out of place for the neighborhood.
- I'm all for new housing (specifically this cute little number), but I understand how sometimes it can all be a bit gauche.
- It's kinda cool. A blend of new and old. It really fits Detroit.
- It looks great. Cool development. Consistency in architectural styles is highly overrated.
- That looks really fucking stupid in Woodbridge.
- I like it! And I like it in the neighborhood!
- The price is a bigger issue. Is Woodbridge worth $350K? That's a bargain considering the quality of construction, but you can pay the same price for a better location in Brush Park.
Back at Curbed, a half-dozen comments include these:
- Love this! This is a great scale for neighborhood infill. Reminds me of neighborhoods in Chicago.
- Very cool. This is how it is done.
- The only thing I dislike is that the building does not have a good top, or "crown". But otherwise, it looks like a great addition to the neighborhood.
Each condo will have two bedrooms, two baths and 1,087 square feet. They're offered here by Alexander Real Estate Detroit, priced at $349,000 (first floor), $359,000 (second) and $369,000.
Kevin M. Hill, the agent, cranks up the hype machine in listing language that speaks of "clean and cutting-edge architecture which balances the need for luxe and urban living." It adds:
"Situated in the historic tree-lined Woodbridge neighborhood, Levels Commonwealth is an urbane oasis in one of Detroit's most thriving communities."
Here's how the 4500 block of Commonwealth looks before excavations on the vacant parcel: